Back to Performance appraisals

How does the appraisal cycle work in ASHR.work?

ASHR.work runs quarterly appraisals with self-review, manager rating, and 360° peer feedback. Ratings use a 5-point scale across five criteria.

~4 min read · For all · Updated 4/21/2026

Quick answer

Each quarter, ASHR.work opens three review stages: the employee completes a self-review using your company's signature reflection framework, the manager rates them on five criteria (5-point scale) and writes an Observation, and 2–4 assigned peers provide 360° feedback. All three feed into one final appraisal.

The three stages

  1. Self-review

    The employee reflects on the quarter using your company's signature reflection framework — a set of prompts spanning failures, accelerations, wins, threats, innovation, feedback and their contribution. Submit when done; after submission it is read-only.
  2. Manager review

    The manager rates the employee on Job Knowledge, Productivity, Communication, Initiative, and Customer Execution (1–5 each), writes the Observation, and submits. The rating is visible to the employee after submission.
  3. 360° peer feedback

    Admins assign 2–4 peers who worked with the employee during the period. Peers submit short feedback in a structured form. Answers are anonymised in the employee's view.

What the employee sees

After the cycle closes, the employee sees their submitted self-review, the manager's rating + Observation, and aggregated (anonymised) peer feedback in one combined view under Reviews → My Appraisals.

What admins can do

  • Open and close cycles from Admin → Settings.
  • Assign peer reviewers from Admin → Peer Assignments.
  • Export the cycle's ratings as CSV for calibration meetings (Phase 2 module).

Frequently asked questions

How often does the appraisal cycle run?
Quarterly by default. Admins can change cadence under Admin → Settings. Each cycle opens a self-review, manager review, and optional peer feedback windows.
What is the rating scale?
A 5-point scale applied to five criteria — Job Knowledge, Productivity, Communication, Initiative, and Customer Execution. The manager also adds an Observation paragraph.
What is the signature reflection framework?
It's a structured reflection framework unique to your company. You name it after your company and core values, and ASHR.work's AI turns it into a memorable acronym where each letter is a reflection prompt — spanning themes like failures, accelerations, wins, threats, innovation, feedback, and each person's contribution. Managers add an Observation. It pushes for an honest retrospective rather than generic self-praise.
Who assigns peer reviewers?
Admins from /admin → Peer Assignments. Each employee is paired with 2–4 peers who worked with them during the review period, with the months-worked value and projects captured for context.